Filed under: News, Adobe, Apple, Freeware, Beta, Web
Adobe claims they don't ship Flash with known crash bugs, user proves they do
Apple's recent iPad product announcement fanned the flames of the Flash debate, namely whether it belongs on Apple's mobile devices -- or not. Since the release of the iPhone Apple has been staunchly against putting Flash on its mobile devices, citing performance and stability issues. In fact at an Apple Town Hall meeting just over a week ago, Steve Jobs said, "When a Mac crashes more often than not it's because of Flash." It doesn't get much more blunt than that.
Adobe, of course, is crying foul, and their chief technology officer Kevin Lynch responded by making the grandiose statement that "Regarding crashing, I can tell you that we don't ship Flash with any known crash bugs, and if there was such a widespread problem historically Flash could not have achieved its wide use today."
Unfortunately, Matthew Dempsky begs to differ, and he can prove it. Before you click that link, you should know that unless you are running the very latest beta version of Flash, it will crash either the Flash plugin, or your entire browser, depending on what browser you are using. The thing is, Dempsky found this crashing bug in September of 2008 and reported it to Adobe then, and the bug has continued to exist in every version of Flash on every platform since.
Lynch's comment is what you'd expect any CTO to say publicly; realistically, what else could he say? It's just very unfortunate for him that someone was able to prove the inaccuracy of his statement in a very compelling way.
If you're tired of Flash giving you troubles, check out the various solutions we've presented by searching Download Squad for "flash block" or "disable flash".
[Update] Adobe has now acknowledged Dempsky's bug report, and has offered an explanation for why it has taken so long to fix it. The explanation is reasonable, but likely won't do anything to dampen the rising level of distaste for Flash that is becoming evident in the online community.
Sushi Cat is one of the cutest Flash games I've ever run across. You play a blue cat with a major talent for eating and, fortunately for you, every level is filled with delicious sushi! The controls are simple: you aim and drop from the top of the screen using the mouse, trying to hit as much sushi as you can on the way down. Eat enough sushi, and you can go on to the next level.
Your score depends on how much sushi you eat, and which bucket the cat lands in when it finally reaches the bottom of the screen. The more ...
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
VD said 8:49AM on 2-08-2010
Didn't crash for me. However I have a newer Flash version (10.0.42.34) than the ones listed in the bug (thank you Firefox), which probably means that the issue has actually been fixed.
I am not on Mac though.
Reply
Jenn said 9:34AM on 2-08-2010
@vd: it crashes in MAC os x only.
Brandon said 9:26AM on 2-09-2010
This is not a mac only problem. It crashed on me an I'm using the latest version of flash with firefox 3.6 in windows 7.
216 said 8:56AM on 2-08-2010
haha that Flashcrash worked sure enough. Cool tho that it only messed up one tab in Google Chrome (and disabled flash in all other tabs)
Reply
Skapig said 9:32AM on 2-08-2010
Adobe loves to turn a blind eye when it can get away with it.
You can further disprove the claim by checking out their own public bug tracker at http://bugs.adobe.com. Filter on Flash Player bugs with a severity of Crash/Hang.
Reply
David Levine said 9:39AM on 2-08-2010
The link did not crash Firefox or IE 7. I have the latest stable release of Flash (not a beta).
Reply
Matt S. said 9:50AM on 2-08-2010
The fact of the matter is... You can't just ditch Flash, at least not a member of hulu or any other video site and want to stay one.
Reply
WilhelmR said 9:52AM on 2-08-2010
Crashes Firefox on windows XP
But not Opera on XP
How come? :P
Reply
holdenpage said 10:16AM on 2-08-2010
Um...
Flash beta is not a stable version, so wtf point is this dude trying to make?
Reply
Jay said 4:55PM on 2-08-2010
The only one that DOESN'T crash is the beta. The others, that Adobe claims ship clean of crash bugs, crash even though he informed them of the bug two years ago. That's the point.
calintel2 said 10:19AM on 2-08-2010
FF 3.5.7 (XP-SP2 ), latest version Flash Player.
Tested with Matthew Dempsky's "Crash Link", (article above).
It immediately crashed my Firefox browser!
Recently, I've been having frequent, unexpected FF crashes,
sometimes when visiting the NYT and other Flash-intensive sites.
At first I thought it was the latest version of FF (3.5.7),
and re-installed an older FF version (3.5.5).
Same thing...frequent crashes!.
Anybody else = problem?
SFdude
Reply
Brian said 4:52PM on 2-11-2010
Yes, I've recently (within last week or so) begun having frequent FF crashes, several times a day. I'm running 3.5.7 and always have multiple windows and tabs open. Any solution would be appreciated. Also, I was unable to install the latest (?) version of Adobe a couple of weeks ago. I forget the error message; it just wouldn't complete the process, and I had to reinstall and earlier version.
Henry said 11:33AM on 2-08-2010
Crashed firefox browser for me.
Chrome crashed but didn't close out.
Opera and IE 8 didn't crash.
Firefox flash plugin version: 10.0.42.34
Chrome: 10,0,42,34
Opera: 10,0,42,34
IE: 10.0.12.36
Reply
TheOneAndOnlyJH said 12:28PM on 2-08-2010
Flash failed in Seamonkey, but didn't crash the browser.
An alert popped up saying "The plug-in performed an illegal operation. You are strongly advised to restart SeaMonkey."
I selected a box to not alert me again until I restart a new browser session and was able to keep browsing. Flash in other tabs didn't work though, but I was able to finish the articles I had open.
Reply
VD said 2:16PM on 2-08-2010
Well, it crashed my home computer, while my work computer was fine, as I said earlier. It may have something to do with the firewall, although it usually plays any Flash site.
The more I look at the description of the bug, I see that while it is a critical issue, it's something that shouldn't bother end users - except if the developer is malicious. Any good developer would see this while programming, and can work around it if he/she really wants to do something like what is described in the testcase (I wouldn't).
I'm not one to approve of Adobe, I am certain they are lazy - they took long enough to develop Linux plugins, and 64bit versions are still only experimental. Not to mention that they promised to open source Flash, but it still far from open.
But I would love if the big companies would use or improve competing technologies, besides just bashing Adobe for their bad products. SVG+SMIL+Javascript can be at least as powerful as Flash for animation and games, but there aren't tools that are as good as Flash for this purpose, and Adobe seems to be unwilling to support SVG more than they do now.
Reply
sahaskatta said 4:00PM on 2-08-2010
Crashed Win 7 with latest version of stable flash and in latest release of Firefox!
Reply
jacob said 4:47PM on 2-08-2010
An app crash is not a Mac crash. The browser died but the OS is fine.
Reply
darwinsurvivor said 5:00PM on 2-08-2010
"if there was such a widespread problem historically Flash could not have achieved its wide use today."
The same can be said about windows, wait...
Reply
Bruce Abernethy said 5:00PM on 2-08-2010
Because the iPhone/iPod never crashes without Flash? Mine usually hangs about once a week and needs a hard reset.
Reply
dmcallis said 5:49PM on 2-08-2010
Actually, Adobe over the weekend did admit this crash and that it is fixed in the beta. Yes, it does impact older versions. And yes, Adobe does accept responsibility.
Take a look at http://blogs.adobe.com/emmy/archives/2010/02/flash_bug_repor.html.
in particular paragraph 3
davemc
Reply