Be Careful Where You Go Green: Znout vs. Greenseng Search
"Going green" is hot right now, and so are Google-based search sites. Znout and Greenseng have combined the two, offering ways to reduce environmental impact while scouring the web.
Znout (Zero Negative Output) has opted for a low-power black background, but unlike Blackle you can change the color if it's really bugging you. Advertising is a bit bothersome, with a large AdSense block atop the page and two sponsored links below, both before your search results.
You'll also notice the Znout favicon replaced by the little blue G, which leads me to believe that Znout has been hastily knocked together to grab some advertising dollars.
Greenseng, on the other hand, displays only the two sponsored links above your results. They've also left all Google's links - images, maps, shopping, news, etc. - intact.
Both Greenseng and Znout display the CO2 Stats "Green" badge, but only Greenseng's actually opened a certificate page. I'm much more convinced that the Greenseng team is doing what they do for the right reasons.
Since there's such a buzz about being environmental, make sure you take claims of being green with a grain of salt. Do a little investigating, and be sure you're supporting the right people!
For now, I'm sticking with Greenseng.
Znout (Zero Negative Output) has opted for a low-power black background, but unlike Blackle you can change the color if it's really bugging you. Advertising is a bit bothersome, with a large AdSense block atop the page and two sponsored links below, both before your search results.
You'll also notice the Znout favicon replaced by the little blue G, which leads me to believe that Znout has been hastily knocked together to grab some advertising dollars.
Greenseng, on the other hand, displays only the two sponsored links above your results. They've also left all Google's links - images, maps, shopping, news, etc. - intact.
Both Greenseng and Znout display the CO2 Stats "Green" badge, but only Greenseng's actually opened a certificate page. I'm much more convinced that the Greenseng team is doing what they do for the right reasons.
Since there's such a buzz about being environmental, make sure you take claims of being green with a grain of salt. Do a little investigating, and be sure you're supporting the right people!
For now, I'm sticking with Greenseng.
So, just how good at time waster games are you? Think you've got the stuff? Well, The World's Hardest Game 2.0 doesn't think you do.
Yes, amazingly, it's possible to have a sequel to a game called "The World's Hardest Game". It doesn't seem logically possible, since if the first one was actually the world's hardest, how could another one come along and share the moniker? It made me doubt the name in the first place. That is, until I tried the game.
The mechanics of the game are very simple. You are a small red square, ...
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Alex L. said 6:13PM on 9-23-2008
Greenseng should at least try to use a black background like Znout does. To save electricity... Hello???
Reply
aanidaani said 6:27PM on 9-23-2008
Modern LCD displays consume more power to produce black than white, just fyi...
Reply
Alex L. said 6:33PM on 9-23-2008
Got any links?
I can't possibly imagine how that would be possible.
I have read many links stating the opposite, the saving may not be as dramatic, but they are there.
aanidaani said 6:33PM on 9-23-2008
http://www.sciam.com/article.cfm?id=fact-or-fiction-black-is
Vlad Zaharia said 6:38PM on 9-23-2008
"This is not the case, however, with LCD monitors, which have no phosphors and represent the lion's share of every new monitored purchased in the developed world, including those used by laptops. Instead, LCD displays rely on an array of thin-tube fluorescent bulbs that provide a constant source of light to create a white screen. To make it black, LCDs rely on a diffuser to block this light. As a result, LCDs use more energy than CRTs to display a black screen. Measuring a 17-inch (43-centimeter) LCD monitor, Schindler found that white required 22.6 watts, while black came in a tad higher at 23.2 watts. With a 20-inch (50.8-centimeter) LCD, black required 6 percent more energy than white."
http://www.sciam.com/article.cfm?id=fact-or-fiction-black-is
Alex L. said 6:38PM on 9-23-2008
Thanks for the link.
I'll be damned.
Lee Mathews said 6:39PM on 9-23-2008
You stole my quote. I'll be damned, too. Thanks for the pro tip!
cowboy_k said 6:41PM on 9-23-2008
Thanks for posting that - I've wondered if the backlight on LCD monitors make the whole black-vs-white-background issue moot, good to see actual evidence of it.
Rocketboy said 9:40AM on 9-24-2008
Don't be so hard on yourselves. I'm sure that you wouldn't actually wouldn't be damed for being wrong on this. I doubt it would even be a slap on the wrist.
Signed,
Larry Literal
Jash Sayani said 3:01AM on 9-24-2008
I go with Google Search.
Reply
Unregistered said 6:42AM on 9-24-2008
do these search engine contribute any money to the green causes? If they don't what's the point of using them?
Reply
Lee Mathews said 9:02AM on 9-24-2008
I suppose the point is that you're at least using a carbon-neutral search engine. I haven't done it, but I imagine a custom google search doesn't generally create a ton of cashflow.
Plus, the engine I was looking at that DID donate money (forestle) got shut down by google. Crappy, hey?
Matt said 10:42AM on 9-24-2008
What a waste of time. Anyone obsessive enough to use a "carbon neutral search engine" - as if the term even means anything - deserves their neurosis.
Reply
boilr said 11:03AM on 9-24-2008
why not use ad-free www.greenr.net ?!
same google custom search except this one is confined to green-only results/sites.
Reply
Rocketboy said 1:02PM on 9-24-2008
I just had a face-palm moment....
How the hell can they consider themselves 'green', when they are a web server that's acting as a middleman between you, and google, who is actually supplying the results? It's like me calling Adam to talk to Betty, when I can just call Betty myself.
Reply
Lee Mathews said 1:02PM on 9-24-2008
They claim to offset consumption by purchasing "Green power." Theoretically, it means you're using slightly more juice, but from a friendlier source.
Rocketboy said 5:32PM on 9-24-2008
Even if all of the power is being generated by people exercising on treadmills, it's still ADDING draw on the rest of the electrical system for all of the other, unallocated, energy usage. Or are they saying that they can accurately gage how much energy that Google is drawing, and how much energy is being wasted on a re-direct, and offset this using fake Carbon Credits? Both of these are a scam in the name of greenwashing.