Filed under: Internet, Windows, Microsoft, Commercial
Internet Explorer 8 renders Acid 2 successfully
by Ian Dumych Dec 20th 2007
Today Web developers everywhere breathed a sigh of relief when Microsoft's Internet Explorer team revealed their latest milestone: IE8 now renders the Acid2 face properly! For those who aren't familiar with this test, Acid2 is designed to determine how compliant a given web browser is with published HTML. A fully compliant browser displays a smiling yellow face. However, non-compliant browsers show varying degrees of garbage.
While we appreciate Microsoft's effort to embrace open web standards (finally), there is something a bit suspicious about the wording of the announcement. Apparently, IE8 only passes the test when operating in something called "Standards Mode".
We can only wonder what Microsoft is up to with such an odd distinction. Will IE8 run in Standards Mode or another mode by default in the future? Only time will tell.
[Via OSNews]
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
Joel I. Johnson said 8:20AM on 12-20-2007
I get the feeling that "Standards Mode" is activated through the use of a certain attribute in the web page. As things stand now IE will change it's rendering and CSS behaviour based on the presence or absence of this attribute.
Reply
bag0rice said 8:30AM on 12-20-2007
well my firefox did poorly on this test
2.0.0.11 Linux
Reply
Ray Merkler said 8:37AM on 12-20-2007
Yeah, Firefox 2 doesn't pass. Firefox 3 will, though.
Ray Merkler said 8:33AM on 12-20-2007
Standards Mode refers to the mode that browsers go into after parsing out the DOCTYPE tag at the top of (responsibly written) HTML documents. When this line is absent, the browsers go into what is called Quirks Mode, which is basically the browser doing whatever it pleases. Nothing fishy about saying that the test only renders correctly in Standards Mode -- that'll be true of any browser.
Reply
Ian Dumych said 4:57PM on 12-20-2007
Well that's good to hear, I was worried it would be something the user had to opt in to.
NathanG said 9:05AM on 12-20-2007
OMG the whole earth is exploding!!
Just kidding well anyways, glad to hear that Microsoft's next browser will be better. It was such a pain to create a standards complaint website and then have it rendered all weird in IE.
Reply
Kelly said 9:08AM on 12-20-2007
The Acid2 test is an utterly meaningless piece of softcore maturbatory material for OCD fetishists. The fact that 99% of all browsers have never passed this test certainly hasn't hindered the development of websites.
Reply
Dan said 9:43AM on 12-20-2007
I respectfully disagree. WebKit (and therefore Safari) passes the Acid2 test. The updated Gecko engine (and therefore FF3) pass the Acid2 test. And now IE8 will pass the test. To say 99% of all browsers haven't passed the test, doesn't really account for the near to immediate future when most browsers will be Acid2-compliant.
James said 3:37PM on 12-20-2007
Yeah, test suites are *so* pointless -- who gives a shit if your code does what it's supposed to, as long as you can get a lot of suckers to use it?
Seriously, the whole point of the acid test is to get everybody rendering HTML consistently, so web developers don't have to resort to hacky per-browser bullshit to make pages appear the way they want them to. Frankly, it's about friggin' time.
HardwareGuy said 9:26AM on 12-20-2007
Firefox 3 beta does pass the Acid2 test. I'm looking forward to a day when all browsers pass so I won't have to modify every website I make just so it can pass through the different hurdles of each browser.
Reply
Whatevar said 9:47AM on 12-20-2007
Not that I care FF is good enough but stop lying, FF3 does not pass the Acid2 test.
I think Standards Mode will be activated if a page use a proper doc type. This made sense doesn't it? You don't want all those old sites to be broken.
Reply
izzy said 10:37AM on 12-20-2007
Firefox 3 beta 2 does indeed pass the Acid 2 test.
Whatevar said 10:47AM on 12-20-2007
Does this look like a propperly rendered smiley to you?
http://img299.imageshack.us/img299/340/acidps3.jpg
Tutor said 12:25PM on 12-20-2007
@Whatevar
The test is broken since yesterday, that's why FF3B2 and others don't pass it right now. No conspiracy involved as far as I know ;-)
https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=289480#c172
And yes, standards compliance is important. It means interoperability and freedom of choice.
Reply
Whatevar said 12:57PM on 12-20-2007
While it's hard to believe the test is "broken". it does seems you're right. I tried it Opera just now and the image gets rendered in about the same way as my picture above. So yes I was wrong. It does look like FF3 would pass the test.
Nathan P said 12:49PM on 12-20-2007
Well, I hope Microsoft FINALLY starts following web standards! The biggest pain for every web developer is debugging and hacking your site so that it looks right in IE.
I'm still clueless as to why they didn't do this with IE7. Oh well, Microsoft will eventually catch up with the Open Source world.
Reply
GMB said 6:16PM on 12-20-2007
Give me a break Opera has been light years ahead in compliance and it hasn't been open source.
Conda said 2:11PM on 12-20-2007
this is good to hear, since they had previously said they didnt care about standards and passing the Acid2 wasnt something theyd particularly strive for
Reply
Adam said 6:16PM on 12-20-2007
Developers won't use products they don't like. If Microsoft wants a snowball's chance in hell of getting silver light off the ground they need developers to start liking them. Making their browser compliant will go a long way to making web developers happy.
Reply
Ian Dumych said 6:49PM on 12-20-2007
As long as they have a working Silverlight Solution on Linux and OS X, I think it will be fine. Of course, there might be complaints from the likes of Richard Stallman, but Adobe Flash isn't open source either, so at least it's not a step backwards.