Filed under: Internet, Blogging, Google
Should Google add comment feature to Reader link blogs?
If you believe the claims in an apparently "leaked" video from Google, there are a few updates headed Google Reader's way. More social features are coming, there will be a way for Reader to recommend feeds to users, and Google might add the ability to comment on shared items.That last one caught the attention of Duncan Riley over at TechCrunch. The way he sees it, allowing users to share articles in a link blog style format already violates the copyright of blog and web site publishers by reproducing their work out of context (and devoid of any original advertising).
Of course, most web publishers have looked the other way so far, because nobody's making any money off of these link blogs, and while entire articles are being reprinted, there's clear attribution explaining where they came from and no way for users to add original content, thus making a link blog something less than a regular blog.
If Google adds the ability to comment on shared items, Riley suggests, then it will essentially be granting users the ability to publish their own blogs using content from others without permission.
Another way of looking at it is that few link blogs (Robert Scoble's included) have the readership of a popular web site like Engadget. If anything, when someone like Robert Scoble shares an occasional item from your feed, he's popularizing your brand and perhaps driving traffic back to your site. After all, he doesn't publish every article you've written, does he? And really, how different is a link blog from an feed reader? In both situations people are reading your content outside of the context of your blog -- because of the RSS feed you have provided them with.
What do you think? Is link blogging stealing? And should Google add a comment feature to Google Reader?
Get a WordPress.com Blog
So, just how good at time waster games are you? Think you've got the stuff? Well, The World's Hardest Game 2.0 doesn't think you do.
Yes, amazingly, it's possible to have a sequel to a game called "The World's Hardest Game". It doesn't seem logically possible, since if the first one was actually the world's hardest, how could another one come along and share the moniker? It made me doubt the name in the first place. That is, until I tried the game.
The mechanics of the game are very simple. You are a small red square, ...
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
kevinDwhite said 1:32PM on 9-12-2007
How about integration between Reader & Blogger? That would be a heck of a lot more useful than adding comments from within Reader. I am becoming more and more convinced that Google has acquired too many little companies and products. The level of integration between different Google products feels like it is plummeting with every acquisition and there doesn't seem to be much effort from Google to do anything about it.
Reply
realgt said 6:29PM on 9-12-2007
linkblogs stealing? no way! they're more like individuals promoting other sites or sites they like, why would any blog publisher complain about free traffic? plus, as you'll notice those feeds all have embedded advertising, so everyones a winner. why not allow comments?
blogscooper.com is a great example of a well maintained linkblog
Reply
Jack said 5:15PM on 9-14-2007
Very interesting post! Thanks )
Reply
gkamp said 9:53AM on 9-13-2007
first i would like to have a mechanism to know about how many people have subscribed to my linkblog, and or the hits coming to the automatically generated linkblog website.
I couldn't find it. Did i miss something.
Reply
DONG JIAN NONG said 5:51PM on 10-02-2007
New Dream web - http://192.168.1.2
From Dream Researcher: DONG JIAN NONG
2007. Okt. 03. Beijing
Reply
wizualizacje-http://www.daymonstudio.pl said 5:46PM on 11-09-2007
Very good information.
Reply
kheder said 7:36AM on 11-12-2007
wow i well test it in my website :
http://games.bnateeen.com
but i think i dont understand
?
Reply