Filed under: Business, Design, News, Windows, Office, Productivity, Microsoft, Commercial
The Office 2007 Ribbon only goes so far
Has anyone noticed that the Ribbon in Office 2007 does not extend to all Office programs? Publisher doesn't have it, as well as some other programs. It seems that Microsoft only saw fit to include in the most loved and used applications like Word, Excel, PowerPoint, and Access. I can't help but brace for the fallout from users. First Microsoft tries to build a "zero-learning-curve" model into their new office suite, hoping that users will find it easier to use and eliminate much of the complexity of the system, which is quite noble, then they don't include it in all the suite's applications? I don't see such a unified front and integrated user experience this time around that Microsoft is always so long-winded about. So this was motivated not by customers' needs or the need for one interface, but by rising costs, looming deadlines, and putting out fires during development? In my x-ray vision, I see far into the future and can't help but wonder if this will help Google (and others) spell doom for at least a good sized portion of Microsoft's cash-cow business? There is already a ton of speculation that Vista will be the last operating system to be released by Microsoft (as far as we know the traditional OS) because the web is now becoming more important than ever. I am hearing that Google's online apps will also spell disaster for Microsoft, perhaps in the next decade or so. Do I agree? Well, the jury is still cherry-picking their favorites, so to speak. I have used Google's apps extensively, including docs and spreadsheets, and I must say that I would rather use Google to get the job done and never have to mess with Office, and I am a long time Office lover. If Microsoft wasn't the standard for everything it wouldn't be hard to find other avenues that suit me just fine (as I have found already). Is the selectively programmed ribbon this important, and will it start the downward climb for our dearly beloved Microsoft? It isn't that deep and probably won't matter to most people. We will either adapt to the multi-mode confusion, use something else, or get over it, but my point is that Microsoft increasingly lets quality and the integrity of their offerings go by the wayside. In addition, I think Microsoft must get on the web-based band-wagon before they are run over by online suites of prey. Desktop office software is a dying breed, as you can tell by looking at the marketplace and the fast-moving mass adoption of many online suites now used in addition to or in place of Office. Microsoft needs to crack the whip and get into the game while there is still time. It has been quite shocking to watch them slowly lose their stranglehold. It is a whole new world today.


Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Herbert Max said 11:18AM on 12-22-2006
Dude, seriously, how about splitting this thing into paragraphs?
Reply
Goo Gibson said 12:14PM on 12-22-2006
Um....Office Live?
Reply
Mike said 12:14PM on 12-22-2006
Well, at least Office includes a means to start a new paragraph. :)
Reply
Mark said 12:15PM on 12-22-2006
I doubt this will spell doom. It isn't really a big deal.
Reply
Frenzisor said 12:16PM on 12-22-2006
Listen, your doom predictions for office are really a waste. Don't try to hype your story with nonsense like this. Office is not going anywhere and you and I and anybody who needs to type anything good will use it. It is by far the best office yet. Have you tried going back to the menu system after using the ribbon? It is terrible. Integration will come into all the programs... later...
Reply
Engaged said 12:17PM on 12-22-2006
Oh the humanity. Oh god yes this will indeed be the end of Microsoft for sure. Ryan Carter you are a genius and a prophet.
I swear, between this guy and Brad Linder whose every post is that "MS abandons customers to the wolves and steal their organs while they sleep" the people writing this blog should put down the crackpipes.
Fine you've all got a raging hatred-on for MS but you could at least not look so stupid about it.
Reply
sdfgsdsdfsdf said 12:18PM on 12-22-2006
I had 2007 installed. Oh my god. It took me twenty minutes to go back to 2003. The new interface is not only terribly ugly, it is also totally unstructured.
And the part that SOUNDED like it could be actually useful (the ribbon itself) is not.
Microsoft should seriously have included "classic modes" for everything.
Reply
Ryan Carter said 12:21PM on 12-22-2006
@Engaged - Does somebody have a case of the fridays?
Reply
Engaged said 12:58PM on 12-22-2006
I have to give you one thing Ryan you made me laugh. This was one of the silliest things I've read in a while. Since I'm pretty much on the sidelines watching, I actually enjoy the sniping from Mac fans at MS.
It's amusing that you guys and Apple spend so much time whining about Microsoft and almost no time talking about what Apple products actually do.
I bet if you asked the average consumer about Apple they could tell you they hate Microsoft but couldn't name 2 products from Apple.
Reply
Fact9 said 1:26PM on 12-22-2006
Is OpenOffice going to die too? Since it's a desktop office software...
Reply
Alex Land said 1:08AM on 12-23-2006
Biased much? I just opened up publisher for the first time since installing office 2007. Seeing as I created a neat looking business card with perhaps 5 clicks, I don't think the ribbon was really needed. I don't feel the need to comment on obvious biases among bloggers very often, but this article is absolutely ridiculous.
Reply
JH said 1:18PM on 12-29-2006
I've been running the office 2007 trial for about a month now and I actually really like the ribbon.
Reply
Ryan Carter said 1:19PM on 12-29-2006
I like it too, I just wish it was more unified across all the apps.
Reply
Stephen Tordoff said 12:53PM on 12-30-2006
The ribbon should be standard across all the Office, as learning a new interface whilst remembering the old is difficult at best
Reply