As more and more computer users are adding microphones and webcams to their PCs for making phone calls, podcasts, or embarrassing videos to post online, the way we think about web content is changing.
Cranky old man voice: Back in my day, I dialed up a BBS with a 2400-baud modem, and if I wanted to "talk" to someone, I'd post a message and wait for a response. Flash forward to 2006 and you've party-line style Skypecasts and teens leaving video responses for one another's YouTube posts.
Australian-based Chinswing is hoping to bridge the gap between the traditional user forum/message board and the modern podcaster. Instead of writing and responding to posted threads in text form, Chinswing lets you have a conversation in non-real time. You create a message headline, then record your entry on the web site (after downloading and installing the free Chinswing Studio software -- sorry, Windows only right now). Then other users can post audio responses to your message.
If you're interested in following a thread but don't have time to listen to it while at the computer, you can download it as a podcast through an RSS feed.
I have to say, the system seems to work very smoothly. It's a nice interface, and easy to use. But I'm not sure it's the best way to organize information. While the company's press release points out that the average person types 50 words per minute, but speaks 160 word per minute, we can read even faster than that. And while I listened through a couple of discussion threads, I found myself hitting the skip button repeatedly after I got tired of waiting for the speaker to make his point. If this were a text-based message board I'd be able to skip ahead easily without missing anything, but once you stop listening to someone, you've pretty much given up on the thread.
I think Chinswing is on to something here. I'm a firm believer that the human voice can carry all sorts of meaning that is hard to express in written words. How often have you tried to write something sarcastic in an email or instant message only to have it taken the wrong way? I'm just not sure that Chinswing will have a wide appeal outside of amateur podcasters. Of course, I'll probably be proven wrong when millions of teenagers grab a microphone and start leaving messages for one another.















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
12-08-2006 @ 4:31PM
Chris Brogan... said...
Is this similar at all to My Chingo from MobaSoft?
Reply
12-08-2006 @ 5:12PM
Michael Bailey said...
Pretty close to the same thing.
But to have yet another site to navigate to just to follow a conversation will probably make their service not be well received.
Blog integration and existing site integration is where they should be headed, not creating yet another island.
Reply
12-08-2006 @ 6:43PM
Dean Worth said...
Creator of Chinswing here (Dean Worth). Just thought I'd comment on the above article and comments. Great to hear some constructive criticism - we're definitely listening.
Text will always be better for some purposes. We're not attempting to replace text forums, but instead provide an enhanced experience for those cases where voice is a more suitable environment. We're focusing more on conversational than "informational" communication - where the journey is greater than the destination. By the way, listening to a discussion about a topic of no interest will always make one "skip-button-happy" ;)
To clarify, MyChingo is an audio commenting system. At Chinswing we group discussions into public interest channels, so the system is browsable, catering to people who want to connect in a rich way with others of similar interests.
By the way, blogger/podcaster and site tools are on the way.
We're eagerly awaiting the millions of teenagers... ;)
Dean.
Reply
12-10-2006 @ 8:44AM
Craig Cmehil said...
I just could not resist it, had to give it a shot they are just starting out and I think they are targeting "teens" - OK I know they are as their creator, Dean Worth, says it in a comment over on Download Squad...
Reply
12-10-2006 @ 8:07PM
Dean Worth said...
Just to clarify... we're NOT specifically targeting only teens. The teenager comment was just a response to the original article that said, "I'll probably be proven wrong when millions of teenagers grab a microphone and start leaving messages for one another". We would, of course, welcome that sequence of events!
So, let me re-phrase... we're eagerly awaiting the millions of teens, young adults, adults and seniors ;-)
Cheers.
Reply
1-15-2007 @ 9:03AM
Sitaram Aryal said...
No
Reply