Download Squad

Thanks for the heads-up on a free alternative to Outlook. Outlook is currently my PIM of choice, but I'm interested in trying this out,

Reply

As an Outlook replacement? I was looking at doing that a while ago, but you had to pay for the exchange connector. Is that still the case? If so, that would be the deal breaker.

Reply

I don't really see the point... Exchange Server only allows "X" users to connect, and your licence provides "X" free licences to Outlook. I suppose there's a limited use for Evolution on Windows if you're NOT running off an Exchange server and you just want to be able to respond to meeting requests, but there's a zillion other ways you can do that -- GMail with Google Calendar to name one.

Reply

It is rather interesting, but not without some challenges. I wrote a bit about it this summer and concluded that I wasn't going to hurry to make the switch.

I guess since Microsoft Outlook already exists for Windows, it's hard to justify using a third-party application that replicates Outlook so completely.

Oh, I can $ee a few rea$on$ why a company might decide to go thi$ route in$tead of buying Outlook... ;-)

Reply

Doh, that middle paragraph in my previous comment is meant to be a quote from your article.

Reply

This windows version kind of stinks. I am a fan of evolution but found the windows version to be lacking. IMAP setups that work under Linux fail to work under windows with no apparent reason. The ical & vcal import is marginal at best. I finally deleted it and went back to using evolution on Linux.

Reply

This sentence:

I'm no lawyer, but I know in my gut when something feels wrong, and this feels wrong.

Should really read like this:

I know in my gut when something feels wrong, and this feels wrong, but I'm no lawyer.

looks like your "editor" goofed again.

Reply

Well, if I recall correctly, evolution is now coming out of Novell, and given Novell's and Microsoft's new arrangement, they probably don't have to worry about being sued.

Reply

It's only copy write infringement if they are using identical code. For most purposes, a GM sedan and a Ford sedan 'look' and work the same, but that does not mean they are infringing on one another. The 'look' can be patented with a design patent, but those are so specific that they are not worth the paper they were printed on.

Reply

Yeah, I'm less worried about litigation than the fact that Evolution is big, clunky, and works like Outlook. :)

Lightning for Thunderbird is really coming along. I vastly prefer Thunderbird -- three-platform support, lightweight, hackable, extensible, and now even syncs with your Windows Mobile device if you like. I find it much more streamlined both in performance and UI than Outlook, or Evolution, for that matter.

Reply

Have you forgotten about the deal that Novell has made with Microsoft? They can use each others intellectual property. And guess what? Look who's behind evolution! Nope, no problems here.

Reply

Evolution has been around for a while [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Novell_Evolution]. Nothing to see here, now move along...

Reply

I get the following error when I try to run Evolution:

GLib-ERROR **: gmem.c:172:failed to allocate 1073741824 bytes aborting...

Anyone else have this problem?

Reply

can i just say, if you're whinging about the interface looking the same as Outlook, what about the KDE environment ? all the close buttons etc look like Vista's ones, and the Start Menu idea is an Microsoft one too...

so if you're going to rip into 1 application for looking similar, then why not push the boat out and look at EVERYTHING OpenSource and pick holes in them and point out everything that looks the same as something else. Solitaire on KDE looks like Solitaire on Windows - quick ! LAWSUIT !

Reply

Don't forget about schools. We have been lookng for an outlook replacement for our windows server for a while. one season as we add student accounts is $$$ another isthe cost of filtering software to protect our email accounts. the reason we can't use gmail etc is in a K-8 enviorment we ned to be able to monitor all email accounts. I hope evolution keeps on developing this program. We need it.

Reply

Hi, only #2 commenter gets the point. If any Outlook replacement can't connect to an Exchange Server natively (sans IMAP/ POP) to sync calendars, contacts, etc, then the app lacks any real value. MUAs that connect to normal mail servers are a commodity. The one that frees me from a Windows OS in order to sync up with corporate info is the one that wins.

-C

Reply

Let's face it, almost all open source software meticulously copies either Microsoft or Apple, both the interface and the functionality. That's about all open source programmers are capable of doing: taking other people's ideas and giving them away.

Reply

Evolution doesn't really connect to an exchange server. It connects to Outlook Web Access over HTTP. It is basically just a front-end for what you can do in a web browser, and seemingly, nothing more. Please correct me if I am wrong.

Reply

I have to say I was a tab bit scared to try this product. I have used other LINUX converted software before to Windows and I haven't had the best experiences. But I will give my negative review first:

First, when I set up my imap and smpt servers, they did not give a place to specify a port. Now knowing how some of these other email clients work, I tried the smtp.aol.com:587 (due to my isp blocking port 25). And it worked, however they should have an example of it above the text box so the average joe might get a clue on how to specify a port.

Then I imported my calendar from Mozilla's Sunbird and that took wow, let 30 minutes to do. I think there could have been other issues going on, but my contacts were ported over fine. Not sure what exactly went on there.

Evolution has crashed on me but nothing to severe. Could have something to do with the fact that I am noticing my computer having problems with the Firefox 2 browser, apparently there is a bug going around.

Overall the user friendliness is like a C+, I wish Mozilla would just merge Thunderbird and Sunbird and that would rock.

Reply

I´ve been using Evolution for six months or so. Mainly for reading my personal mail at work thru IMAP, and it works fine.
At home I use MS Outlook with POP, but want to move away from it since I´ve used OpenOffice for several years as an Office replacement, and don´t really need MS Office. Other than Outlook that is.

Problem with Evolution is:
- it does´nt import Outlook .pst-format (must export from Outlook into csv.format first)
- importing mail into Evo to the correct location seems undoable
- screws up import of "foreign" charachters, ie. swedish ones (åäö)

So, am I stuck with Outlook?

Reply