With little fanfare Microsoft released Windows Media Player 11 in beta form last week coupled with Urge, the music service from Microsoft and MTV designed to compete with Apple's iTunes Music Store. WMP11 is a sort of preview of what we can expect to see next year in Windows Vista, and the question that seems to be on everyone's minds is whether Microsoft can finally best Apple's rock-solid player and service. According to the Washington Post's Rob Pegoraro, at least, the answer is no. His article can be summed up by its title, "New Media Player: Nice Features, but It's No iTunes." Pegoraro says that WMP11 has a cleaner interface that represents "a smart, creative way to organize a digital music library" and catches up with iTunes in a number of respects, like its ever-present live search box and easy CD burning functionality. Its album artwork downloader, however, is bewilderingly inept. Pegoraro's review of Urge, which has both a la cart ($0.99/song, $9.99/per album) and subscription (rent your music for $9.99 a month) options, is less favorable, saying, "Not only has MTV failed to match iTunes, it has repeated some of the worst mistakes of earlier iTunes challengers." He criticizes the service's lack of extras like lyrics and bonus videos, irritating search behaviors, and the lack of iPod support that has become a cliché among iTunes' competitors. Head over to the Washington Post for the full review or Microsoft's web site if to bite the bullet and try Windows Media Player 11 out yourself.Is Windows Media Player 11 an iTunes-killer?
With little fanfare Microsoft released Windows Media Player 11 in beta form last week coupled with Urge, the music service from Microsoft and MTV designed to compete with Apple's iTunes Music Store. WMP11 is a sort of preview of what we can expect to see next year in Windows Vista, and the question that seems to be on everyone's minds is whether Microsoft can finally best Apple's rock-solid player and service. According to the Washington Post's Rob Pegoraro, at least, the answer is no. His article can be summed up by its title, "New Media Player: Nice Features, but It's No iTunes." Pegoraro says that WMP11 has a cleaner interface that represents "a smart, creative way to organize a digital music library" and catches up with iTunes in a number of respects, like its ever-present live search box and easy CD burning functionality. Its album artwork downloader, however, is bewilderingly inept. Pegoraro's review of Urge, which has both a la cart ($0.99/song, $9.99/per album) and subscription (rent your music for $9.99 a month) options, is less favorable, saying, "Not only has MTV failed to match iTunes, it has repeated some of the worst mistakes of earlier iTunes challengers." He criticizes the service's lack of extras like lyrics and bonus videos, irritating search behaviors, and the lack of iPod support that has become a cliché among iTunes' competitors. Head over to the Washington Post for the full review or Microsoft's web site if to bite the bullet and try Windows Media Player 11 out yourself.













Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
5-22-2006 @ 2:45PM
David G. Hong said...
The difference between WMP10 and WMP11 with regards its library managing feature - is almost nil. Need something much more simpler than that if they want people to be actually utilising it properly.
Reply
5-22-2006 @ 3:23PM
Blue_Chi said...
The WMP11 is the MEDIA PLAYER, while URGE is the music store service. I personally do not think that iTunes MEDIA PLAYER has anything special at all, the Windows MEDIA PLAYER has many more playlist settings and library configurations options, iTunes is way too simple for me. However, the iTunes MUSIC STORE ease of us is obviously Apple's winning point, not the iTunes MEDIA PLAYER.
Reply
5-22-2006 @ 4:15PM
Rkmase said...
I will give it one thing - It is pretty.
Reply
5-22-2006 @ 5:01PM
Wry Cooter said...
But, you know that MTV gives its staff custom finished ibooks or powerbooks though? They are Candy Apple Red.
Reply
5-22-2006 @ 9:04PM
Cameron said...
I have just downloaded the windows media player 11 beta and it is completly CRAP. Yes new design, yes some cool features and yes they are trying to enter the download market with URGE but come on, I can't view the playlist by sorting in artist or even songs. There is always a friggin picture of the album which I don't want and there are features which you can not dissable. Also on the now playing list, you can not scroll with the middle mouse scroller.
I know it is a beta version but I seriously hope they do not release it exactly the same. I am for now very happy with win media 10.
Reply